At every great restaurant, certain menu items rise above the rest—not just because they taste good, but because they connect with people. At
Casa-Bella Pizza, a beloved local favorite in Medfield, those standout dishes have earned a special place in the hearts (and stomachs) of regulars.
From bubbling pizzas to hearty pastas, cheesy subs to crisp salads,
Casa-Bella’s most popular dishes are the ones customers order again and again. In this blog, we’ll reveal the top picks across the menu—based on real customer favorites, online reviews, and insider tips from the Casa-Bella team.
Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a regular looking to try something new, this list is your guide to
the most-loved dishes at Casa-Bella Pizza.
🍕 1. The CasaBella Special Pizza
Why It’s a Favorite:
This pizza is
loaded—the kind of pie that turns heads when it comes out of the oven. The
CasaBella Special brings together the perfect mix of meats and veggies: pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers, and black olives, all on a bed of house-made sauce and mozzarella.
What Makes It Special:
- Balanced flavors and textures
- Hand-tossed dough with crispy edges
- Every bite packed with toppings
- Perfect for sharing
If you're trying Casa-Bella for the first time, this is the pizza to start with.
🌶️ 2. The Buffalo Built Pizza
Why It’s a Favorite:
Spicy, creamy, and wildly addictive, the
Buffalo Built is a flavor bomb. It features grilled buffalo chicken, mozzarella cheese, and a final drizzle of ranch dressing that ties it all together.
What Makes It Special:
- Bold buffalo sauce that’s not too hot
- Juicy grilled chicken
- Cool ranch drizzle for contrast
- Great for sports nights or casual dinners
It’s become a go-to for customers who want a break from the classics—but still crave comfort food.
🍝 3. Chicken Alfredo Pasta
Why It’s a Favorite:
Rich, creamy, and satisfying, the
Chicken Alfredo is a dish that delivers every time. Tender grilled chicken sits atop a bed of fettuccine noodles tossed in a velvety Alfredo sauce made in-house.
What Makes It Special:
- House-made sauce using real cream and parmesan
- Generous chicken portions
- Comes with garlic bread for dipping
- Great as a solo meal or paired with a salad
It’s comfort food at its best—and one of the
most ordered pasta dishes at Casa-Bella.
🥪 4. Chicken Parm Sub
Why It’s a Favorite:
A crispy chicken cutlet, tangy marinara, and melted mozzarella cheese, all nestled in a warm Italian roll? Yes, please. The
Chicken Parm Sub is a lunchtime staple that often becomes dinner too.
What Makes It Special:
- Breaded chicken fried to order
- Toasted roll for crunch and softness
- Plenty of cheese—no skimping here
- Served hot and fast
Whether you’re eating in or grabbing it to go, this is a sub that satisfies.
🥗 5. Antipasto Salad
Why It’s a Favorite:
Not all customer favorites are heavy. The
Antipasto Salad is a fan favorite for its freshness, color, and protein-packed ingredients. It combines lettuce, tomatoes, olives, pepperoni, provolone, and banana peppers, all tossed with a zesty vinaigrette.
What Makes It Special:
- Large portion—enough to share or save
- Great balance of vegetables and savory meats
- Ideal side for pizza or a light standalone meal
- Available with added grilled chicken
Customers love it as a starter or as a lighter alternative to pizza.
🍝 6. Baked Ziti
Why It’s a Favorite:
This classic
Italian-American comfort food never goes out of style. Baked ziti at Casa-Bella is made with penne pasta, marinara, ricotta, and mozzarella, then oven-baked to bubbly perfection.
What Makes It Special:
- Layers of cheese and sauce in every bite
- Hot and crispy from the oven
- Available in family trays for catering
- Excellent value for portion size
Perfect for cozy nights at home—or feeding a hungry crew.
🍕 7. White Pizza
Why It’s a Favorite:
A refreshing change from red sauce pizzas, the
White Pizza features a base of garlic olive oil, creamy ricotta, and mozzarella. It’s a subtle, elegant option with bold flavor.
What Makes It Special:
- No red sauce—just cheese, garlic, and herbs
- Pairs beautifully with a salad or wine
- Can be topped with spinach, tomato, or chicken
- Light but satisfying
It’s especially popular with customers looking for something unique or vegetarian-friendly.
🧄 Honorable Mentions
While the above dishes lead the pack, other crowd-pleasers include:
- Mozzarella Sticks – Crispy, gooey, and a must-try appetizer
- Steak & Cheese Sub – Juicy steak, melted cheese, soft roll
- Garlic Knots – Perfect side, especially for dipping in marinara
Casa-Bella’s menu offers something for every craving—and most dishes are customizable, making it easy to find your own favorite.
💬 What Customers Are Saying
“The CasaBella Special is hands-down the best pizza I’ve had in Medfield. Loaded with toppings and super flavorful.” – Kevin M.
“The Buffalo Built is our Friday night ritual. My kids and I love it. Spicy but not overpowering.” – Sarah T.
“I get the Chicken Alfredo every time. It’s better than most Italian restaurants around here.” – Tom R.
Positive word-of-mouth and glowing reviews have helped make these dishes staples for loyal customers across Medfield.
❓ FAQs About Casa-Bella’s Most Popular Dishes
Q: Can I customize these menu items?
A: Yes! You can adjust toppings, choose gluten-free crusts, or add extras to most items.
Q: Are these dishes available for catering or large groups?
A: Absolutely. Most of Casa-Bella’s pizzas, pastas, and subs are available in tray or platter sizes for events.
Q: Are there vegetarian options among customer favorites?
A: Yes. The White Pizza, Antipasto Salad (without meats), and several pastas can be made vegetarian.
Q: What’s a good dish to try if I’m new to Casa-Bella?
A: Start with the CasaBella Special Pizza or Chicken Parm Sub—they’re top sellers and reflect what customers love most.
Try the Most Popular Dishes at Casa-Bella Pizza
Whether you’re stopping in for lunch, ordering dinner for the family, or planning your next gathering, these
popular dishes at Casa-Bella Pizza are guaranteed to satisfy. With something for everyone—and every flavor craving—you’re bound to discover a new favorite.
📍
Visit us at: 454 Main Street, Medfield, MA
📞
Call to order: (508) 359-4040
💻
View full menu or order online: www.casabellamedfield.com
Experience the food Medfield locals can’t get enough of.
Casa-Bella Pizza: where quality, flavor, and community come together on every plate.
